25 Legal Traps New Criminal Laws (BNSS BNS BSA 2023) – Avoid These Common Mistakes

A Practical Guide by Advocate Saurabh Savara, Practising at the High Court of Punjab & Haryana, Chandigarh.

Legal traps new criminal laws under the Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita (BNSS), Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita (BNS), and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam (BSA) 2023 are more common than you think. These new laws introduced stricter timelines, procedural safeguards, technology integration, and citizen protections. This article provides general educational information on 25 key legal traps.

Trap 001: Misunderstanding the Enforcement of Notarised Agreements

Keywords: notarised agreements registration, enforceability. Relevant Sections: Section 35 BNSS, Section 63 BNS. Notarisation only verifies identity and signatures. It does not replace mandatory registration under the Registration Act, 1908, for certain documents such as property transfers. General Information: Parties should ensure compliance with registration requirements where applicable.

Trap 002: Ignorance of Police Power to Arrest Without Warrant

Keywords: arrest without warrant rights, cognizable offences. Relevant Sections: Section 35 BNSS, Section 47 BNSS. Police may arrest without a warrant in cognizable offences if conditions are met and reasons are recorded. General Information: Individuals may request the arrest memo and grounds of arrest as per procedure.

Trap 003: Lack of Knowledge About Bail Eligibility in Non-Cognizable Offences

Keywords: bail in non-cognizable offences, summons vs arrest. Relevant Sections: Section 41A BNSS, Section 57 BNSS. Summons is the general rule for non-cognizable offences. General Information: Awareness of procedural distinctions can help citizens understand their position.

Trap 004: Invalidity of Self-Serving Documents in Legal Disputes

Keywords: electronic evidence, 65B certificate, BSA. Relevant Sections: Section 63 BSA, Section 63 BNS. Electronic records require a certificate under Section 63 BSA for admissibility in court. General Information: Proper certification supports evidentiary value.

Trap 005: Not Filing an FIR Timely

Keywords: FIR filing delays. Relevant Sections: Section 173 BNSS, Section 164 BNS. Delays may impact evidence preservation. General Information: Prompt action is generally advisable.

Trap 006: Absence of Legal Notice in Cheque Bounce Cases

Keywords: cheque bounce legal notice. Relevant Sections: Section 138 NI Act (procedural aspects under BNSS). Notice within 30 days of dishonour is a statutory requirement. General Information: Compliance with notice procedures is important.

Trap 007: Assuming Arrest is Mandatory After FIR

Relevant Sections: Section 35(3) BNSS. General Information: Notice of appearance applies in many cases (offences punishable up to 7 years).

Trap 008: Ignoring Timelines for Investigation and Charge Sheet

Relevant Sections: Section 193 BNSS (charge sheet), Section 187 BNSS (timelines). General Information: Investigation timelines are prescribed; awareness may help in understanding procedural progress.

Trap 009: Misusing or Overlooking Anticipatory Bail Provisions

Keywords: anticipatory bail, pre-arrest protection. Relevant Sections: Section 482 BNSS. Anticipatory bail protects from arrest in non-bailable offences when there is apprehension of arrest. General Information: Applications are to be made before the Sessions Court or High Court. Timely consideration of this provision in appropriate cases may be relevant.

Trap 010: Presenting Unstamped or Improperly Stamped Documents

Keywords: stamp duty, document admissibility. Relevant Sections: Relevant provisions under the Indian Stamp Act (read with BNSS/BSA procedures). Documents not properly stamped may face admissibility issues or penalties. General Information: Ensuring proper stamp duty as per applicable state laws supports validity.

Trap 011: Not Recording Arrest Procedure Properly

Keywords: arrest rights, medical examination, grounds of arrest. Relevant Sections: Sections 36, 47, 52 BNSS. Procedural safeguards during arrest include informing the grounds, the right to inform family, and medical examination. General Information: Proper documentation of the arrest procedure is part of legal safeguards.

Trap 012: Relying Solely on Verbal Police Assurances

Keywords: written documentation, police assurances. Relevant Sections: Various procedural sections under BNSS (e.g., arrest and investigation). Verbal assurances carry limited legal weight compared to written records. General Information: It is generally advisable to seek written communication in official matters.

Trap 013: Delaying Victim Compensation Claims

Keywords: victim rights, compensation. Relevant Sections: Relevant victim compensation provisions under BNSS (e.g., Sections 396-398 approx.). New laws emphasise victim rights, including compensation. General Information: Timely action regarding victim rights may be beneficial.

Trap 014: Ignoring Mandatory Forensic Investigation Requirements

Keywords: forensic investigation, serious offences. Relevant Sections: Section 176(3) BNSS. Forensic investigation is mandatory for offences punishable with 7 years or more. General Information: This provision strengthens evidence collection in serious cases.

Trap 015: Wrongly Assuming All Offences Allow Immediate Arrest

Keywords: cognizable vs non-cognizable, arrest exceptions. Relevant Sections: Section 35 BNSS.The distinction between cognizable and non-cognizable offences determines arrest powers. General Information: Not all offences permit immediate arrest.

Trap 016: Failing to Preserve Digital Evidence Chain of Custody

Keywords: digital evidence, chain of custody, BSA. Relevant Sections: Section 63 BSA. Proper preservation and certification of digital evidence is essential for admissibility. General Information: Maintaining the chain of custody supports evidentiary integrity.

Trap 017: Not Seeking Magistrate Intervention for FIR Refusal

Keywords: FIR refusal, Magistrate approach. Relevant Sections: Section 173 BNSS (and related). If police refuse to register an FIR, remedies before the Magistrate or the Superintendent of Police exist. General Information: Citizens may approach higher authorities or the Magistrate in case of refusal.

Trap 018: Misunderstanding Community Service as Punishment

Keywords: community service, alternative punishment. Relevant Sections: Relevant provisions under BNS. Community service is introduced as an alternative punishment for certain minor offences. General Information: Awareness of sentencing options under new laws is useful.

Trap 019: Overlooking Rights During Police Custody

Keywords: custody rights, family information, medical check. Relevant Sections: Sections 47, 52 BNSS. Rights include informing family/relatives and medical examination. General Information: These safeguards protect individuals in custody.

Trap 020: Using Expired Cheque Presentation Periods

Keywords: cheque validity, presentation period. Relevant Sections: Section 138 NI Act. Cheques must be presented within the validity period (generally 3 months). General Information: Timely presentation is required for legal recourse.

Trap 021: Assuming Notarisation Equals Registration for All Documents

Keywords: notarisation vs registration. Relevant Sections: Section 35 BNSS, Section 63 BNS. Notarisation and registration serve different purposes; registration is mandatory for certain documents. General Information: Distinguishing between the two is important for enforceability.

Trap 022: Ignoring Preliminary Enquiry Requirements

Keywords: preliminary enquiry, certain cases. Relevant Sections: Section 173 BNSS.A preliminary enquiry may be required before registering FIR in specific categories of cases. General Information: This helps in filtering frivolous complaints.

Trap 023: Not Filing for Default Bail Timely

Keywords: default bail, charge sheet delay. Relevant Sections: Section 187 BNSS. If a charge sheet is not filed within 60/90 days (as applicable), the accused may be entitled to default bail. General Information: This is a statutory right that requires a timely application.

Trap 024: Presenting Screenshots Without Proper Certification

Keywords: screenshots, electronic evidence certification. Relevant Sections: Section 63 BSA. Screenshots and other electronic records need proper certification for court admissibility. General Information: Compliance with BSA requirements is necessary.

Trap 025: Believing New Laws Automatically Favour One Side

Keywords: balanced procedures, rights and duties. Relevant Sections: Various provisions across BNSS, BNS, and BSA. The new laws aim for balance with timelines and safeguards for all stakeholders. General Information: Understanding both rights and obligations promotes better compliance.

Note for Next Blog: Future articles may cover additional general aspects such as property disputes and victim rights under the new framework.

Disclaimer: This article is for general educational and informational purposes only. It does not constitute legal advice, does not create any advocate-client relationship, and should not be relied upon as a substitute for professional legal counsel. The provisions of BNSS, BNS, and BSA 2023 are subject to judicial interpretation and possible amendments. Readers are advised to consult a qualified advocate enrolled with the Bar Council for any specific legal issues. The author and platform expressly disclaim any liability for any loss or damage arising from the use of this information. This content complies with Rule 36 of the Bar Council of India Rules and is not intended to solicit work or advertise legal services in any manner.

CTA: Share this article to promote general legal awareness among citizens